Best of Week 12: Georgia returns to form, Oregon escapes and Travis Hunter takes control of the Heisman race

Georgia entered Week 12 in an unusual place. Coming off an emphatic loss to Ole Miss, the Bulldogs were scuffling, looking for answers, and if the season had ended on Tuesday with the College Football Playoff committee's most recent rankings, they'd have been on the outside looking in.

We had become accustomed to Georgia's dominance at all turns. The close games were more a product of boredom than any actual defect, and the losses, rare as they were, were offered as little more than tribute to Nick Saban, the man who had sent Kirby Smart to lead Georgia to the promised land.

But in 2024, even amid the wins, things have just felt ... off.

There has been the familiar parade of players landing in legal hot water away from the field. There has been the rising frustration with offensive coordinator Mike Bobo. There's the gut-wrenching losses to bitter rivals that seem destined to doom the Bulldogs to second-class status. If this were pro wrestling, the first notes of "Jesus, Take the Wheel" would begin playing and Mark Richt would emerge from the tunnel, revealing he had been in charge all along.

On Saturday, however, we got our reminder that this isn't the Georgia of old, even if it's not quite the Georgia of 2021 and 2022 either. In a game that felt almost algorithmically engineered to prove the Dawgs had addressed each of their most blatant faults, Carson Beck and crew devoured Tennessee, 31-17, and reasserted dominion over college football -- if not officially in the standings, then certainly in the hearts and minds of every team who might have the misfortune of drawing the Dawgs in the playoff.

Beck, who had thrown 12 interception in his past six games, was nearly flawless Saturday. He threw for 346 yards and totaled three touchdowns, but more importantly, he looked supremely confident with each fastball he delivered downfield.

The offensive line, which handed out party favors to Ole Miss pass rushers en route to he backfield last week, held its own against one of the most ferocious defensive fronts in the country. Beck wasn't sacked, and Tennessee managed just two tackles for loss in the game.

The ground game, scrambling for answers and without injured starter Trevor Etienne, turned to Nate Frazier and, in so many critical moments, Beck to provide the spark. They delivered a pair of rushing touchdowns as proof of life for a backfield that had so often looked dormant.

So it is, too, that Georgia has life in the crowded SEC.

Certainly SEC fans are too modest to say it, but the fact its, the league is pretty good this year. We entered Week 12 with a logjam of teams with a loss or two or three, but a résumé warranting real playoff consideration. The depth of talent threatened to overwhelm the conference, however, with the committee inserting four Big Ten teams in the top five and leaving Saban to lament to Pat McAfee that the committee can't "just look at the record," echoing Greg Sankey's long-held belief that wins are an overrated metric compared to things like revenue, attendance or prevalence of cowbells.

But Saturday proved to be something of a palette cleanser for the SEC -- like the white bread that comes with Dreamland ribs. While a handful of teams took a mental health day -- Alabama, Auburn, Texas A&M and Kentucky all played lower-tier competition and won by a combined 154 points -- the rest of the slate helped clarify something akin to a pecking order.

In Gainesville, the Billy Napier redemption tour continued, with DJ Lagway and Elijhah Badger leading the Florida charge on a 27-16 win over LSU. After the game, Napier celebrated the Gators' fifth win of the season by calling human resources at Zaxby's and letting them know he won't be able to start on Dec. 1 as previously promised, now needing just a win over either Ole Miss or (more likely) Florida State to secure a bowl.

LSU, meanwhile, is effectively cooked in the chase for the playoff after the loss, and it's possible Brian Kelly's anger management classes are no longer covered by his insurance.

After the game, Kelly lambasted the team asking of his players, "Do you want to fight or not?" It was not immediately clear if he meant in LSU's remaining games or in the parking lot out back as soon as his press conference was over. Either way, things are bleak in Baton Rouge. It's sad to see a situation where everyone felt like faaaamily devolve into something completely inauthentic.

If LSU is tumbling in the SEC standings, however, Saturday was South Carolina 's time to shine against Missouri.

LaNorris Sellers threw for 353 yards and five touchdowns and continued to treat pass rushers softballs bouncing off a fungo.

What started as a defensive tussle ended with four touchdowns -- two by each offense -- in the game's final 9:12. The Gamecocks took a 27-22 lead with 5:04 to play on Sellers' fourth TD pass of the game, only to see Brady Cook and Luther Burden III hook up on a gorgeous 37-yard bomb to regain the lead with just over a minute to go.

But South Carolina had an answer, marching 70 yards on six plays in just 47 seconds, culminating with a 15-yard touchdown run by Rocket Sanders to secure the win. That Shane Beamer didn't celebrate by head-butting a player still wearing his helmet really shows how far he has come as a coach this season.

So here's where things stand amid the rubble of another Saturday in the SEC: Texas and Texas A&M are atop the standings at 5-1, but they'll play each other in Week 14. Georgia, Tennessee, Ole Miss and Alabama all have two losses, but each have secured a win vs. at least one of the other tied teams, leaving their fate to the SEC's arcane tie-breaker policies which involve opponent records, scoring differentials and a pie-eating contest between Lane Kiffin and Josh Heupel. And, of course, there's still South Carolina, looming on the fringes of the playoff debate at 7-3.

The case for the SEC's supremacy is clear. With seven teams playing such high level football, all losses come with an asterisk and all wins feel epic. In that case, Georgia's two losses and occasionally confounding struggles will pale in comparison to the immense talent on the roster, and this win over Tennessee will be Exhibit A for why the road to the national championship still runs through Athens.

But the path toward the SEC's demise is also clear: Either the committee fails to reward depth or, more likely, in a fit of rage, Kelly uses a flame thrower he bought on the dark web to burn the entire conference to the ground.

Jump to:
Ducks hold off Badgers | Hunter's Heisman case
Klubnik delivers late | USC finds a spark | Irish roll
Tulane capsizes Navy | Week 12 trends
Heisman five | Under the radar

Ducks D plays big

The College Football Playoff committee is going to have to take a hard look at Wisconsin this week. With a three-point loss to No. 1 Oregon, the Badgers now have a top-five résumé.

More importantly, the committee won't have to select a new No. 1, as Oregon's defense came up big in a grueling 16-13 win.

Dillon Gabriel finished with 218 passing yards and an interception, just the second time in 60 career starts that he threw a pick without also throwing a touchdown. Instead, the Ducks relied on tailback Jordan James to lead a second-half comeback after falling behind 13-6. James finished with 25 carries for 121 yards and a game-tying TD with 13:14 to go in the fourth quarter.

It was Matayo Uiagalelei who sealed the win, however. Wisconsin got the ball at its own 17 with 1:26 to play, but Jamaree Caldwell tipped a Braedyn Locke pass, and Uiagalelei caught the carom for the game-sealing INT. (Note to Florida State fans: It is possible for the words "Uiagalelei" and "interception" to appear in a sentence not involving a brutal loss.)

The win keeps Oregon undefeated and headed toward a Big Ten title game berth, but it's not without some red flags. Wisconsin held the Ducks to just 354 total yards -- a week after Oregon mustered just 363 against Maryland. That's the first time Oregon has had back-to-back games with fewer than 400 yards of offense since 2020.

On the other hand, winning games while accumulating a frustratingly limited number of yards and relying on a power run game and a stout defense suggests Oregon has acclimated nicely into the Big Ten's way of life.

---

Hunter states Heisman case

Colorado is still coming, according to Deion Sanders, but according to the Big 12 standings, the Buffaloes are already there.

Coach Prime lamented a less-than-exceptional performance by his Buffs in a 49-24 win over Utah, and yet there's little other than platitudes in the aftermath. Colorado is in command of the No. 2 spot in the Big 12, and if it wins out against Kansas and Oklahoma State, a date in the conference title game is assured.

Shedeur Sanders struggled early against the Utes' defense, but he ultimately finished with 340 yards passing and three touchdowns in Colorado's usual demoralizing fashion.

I swear every Colorado offensive play is Shedeur scrambling 40 yards in the backfield until the pass rushers collapse in exhaustion, heaves 60 yards downfield, watches as DB trips over own shoe laces.

— 💫🅰️♈️🆔 (@ADavidHaleJoint) November 16, 2024

Meanwhile, after a season-ending injury to Brandon Rose, Utah turned to Isaac Wilson, who is actually just an AI-generated representation of what a Utah QB might be after feeding Rose, Nate Johnson, Bryson Barnes, Charlie Brewer and Jake Bentley into the algorithm. The important takeaway here, however, is he's not Cam Rising, so of course, Utah struggled. Wilson lost a fumble and threw three interceptions in the game, including one to Travis Hunter, who struck a Heisman pose afterward.

Hunter caught five passes for 55 yards, and after Coach Prime checked the rule book and learned his team was also allowed to run the ball, Hunter got a carry that also went for a 5-yard touchdown. On the downside, Hunter did allow his first TD of the season in coverage, a 40-yard dart to Dorian Singer in the third quarter.

With the win, Colorado moves to 8-2 -- just the second eight-win season for the program in the past 20 years, making it likely other teams will attempt to copy Sanders' program-building blueprint of bringing in a whole bunch of transfers, at least one of whom is the best player in the country.

---

Klubnik delivers late win

Pitt hosted Clemson on Saturday in a game that figured to settle any debate over who was the third-best team in the ACC, which is like RC Cola and Shasta getting into a slap fight over cola rankings.

The results often looked like two teams who didn't exactly warrant their space on the playoff periphery, too.

Clemson had third-and-21
Pitt penalty, offsides
Pitt penalty, offsides
Pitt penalty, offsides
Clemson throws incomplete on third-and-6.
Brilliant defensive design from the Panthers.

— 💫🅰️♈️🆔 (@ADavidHaleJoint) November 16, 2024

Indeed, Pitt followed up that defensive series with one of the most mind-numbing offensive stretches possible. The officials missed a clear false start on second-and-goal, but Pitt was stuffed. Pitt called a timeout to avoid a delay of game, then was flagged for an illegal formation, then was flagged for a delay of game, then topped the whole thing off with a penalty for a false start before ultimately kicking a field goal.

Could those four points Pitt left on the field have helped?

The Panthers actually erased a 17-7 deficit in the fourth quarter to take a 20-17 lead, but on a second-and-3, Clemson QB Cade Klubnik took a QB sneak up the middle and scrambled virtually untouched for 50 yards and a score. Pitt's last-gasp drive stalled at the Tigers' 26, and Clemson held on for a 24-20 win that was marked by abysmal O-line play, missed opportunities and some astonishingly questionable officiating.

Afterward, Pitt coach Pat Narduzzi summed up the game by utilizing all seven of George Carlin's words you can't say on TV and also making up several new ones.

---

USC finds a spark

After climbing to No. 11 in the AP poll in September, USC entered Week 12 losers of five of its past seven, with all five losses coming by a touchdown or less.

After opening the season 5-1, Nebraska entered Week 12 losers of three straight, two by a touchdown or less.

USC made a QB change, giving UNLV transfer Jayden Maiava the start. Nebraska made a change at offensive playcaller, with Dana Holgorsen emerging from his basement to see daylight for the first time in 11 months and recoiling in horror.

Both teams were in desperate straits, and they met at the Coliseum on Saturday to chase something approaching credibility like two pigeons fighting for half a discarded baloney sandwich.

The game didn't disappoint.

USC led 14-7, Nebraska charged back to take a 17-14 lead, USC scored to jump ahead by a point, then found the end zone again on a 2-yard Maiava TD run with 2:45 to play.

The game was in Holgorsen's hands from there.

After being fired despite what he had called "an impossible buyout" at Houston last year, Holgorsen had largely disappeared from the public eye, focusing instead on the finer things in life. But Saturday was like the montage scene in any '80s movie where the down-and-out character resolves to get his life together, showers, shaves and puts on a new suit, emerging like a conquering hero. Only Holgorsen didn't shower or shave and may have been wearing a Nebraska hoodie that Mike Riley left in a desk drawer 10 years ago after splilling some spaghetti on it.

Dana Holgorsen thinking about the damage Marcus Satterfield did on Faux Patrick Mahomes. #GBR pic.twitter.com/t819JpeyrU

— Trent McGee (@stmcgee) November 16, 2024

But there was still a little Holgo magic left, and Dylan Raiola and the Huskers marched to the USC 14 with 5 seconds to play and a chance to tie the game.

But we know how this story ends. It always ends this way for the Huskers.

USC prevailed 28-20. Nebraska has now lost 38 one-possession games since the start of the 2017 season -- 10 more than any other Power 4 school. After getting to win No. 5 in each of the past two seasons, it has subsequently lost a combined eight straight, seven of them by one-possession.

Dante's ninth circle of hell is called "treachery." Then there are like 14 more he didn't write about, one of which involves being really into downloading bootleg Nickelback live shows, and then you finally reach something approaching where Nebraska fans are at right now.

---

Leonard, Irish roll

In 2014, Notre Dame and the ACC entered into a scheduling agreement in which the Irish promised five matchups per year against the conference in exchange for a home for their non-football programs. Since then, Notre Dame has effectively been Biff from "Back to the Future" to the ACC's McFly family. They roll into the house unannounced, raid the fridge and eat Wake Forest's leftover chicken and then take Georgia Tech's car without asking.

And so it was that the Irish throttled Virginia 35-14 on Saturday behind Riley Leonard's three touchdown throws. Jeremiyah Love ran for 137 and the defense picked off Anthony Colandrea three times. Notre Dame finishes 5-0 against the ACC, the sixth time in 11 years the Irish have gone undefeated against the conference in the regular season. Overall, Notre Dame is 50-9 in the regular season against the ACC since 2014, including a 9-0 record as a full member in 2020, and somewhere Jack Swarbrick is inviting his buddies to crash at John Swofford's beach house for the entire summer again.

---

Tulane capsizes Navy

The rigging was set, the masts were raised, ye old Navy set sail for a win. But before it had reached shore, the Green Wave climbed all aboard, and plundered its gold and its gin.

Yo ho, yo ho, to the league championship game they go.

If Tulane ain't the best on all seven seas, certainly it's tops on at least five. And before it was done, it had won 35 to none, keeping their playoff hopes still alive.

Yo ho, yo ho, to the league championship game they go.

He threw for two scores and ran for one more, Darian Mensah did everything right. The corners and pass blockers, put Navy in Davy Jones locker, now the Wave turn attention to the Army Black Knights.

Yo ho, yo ho, to the league championship game they go.

The steely men of fair Tulane, a right fine crew be they. They fight and they tussle, they're all brawn and muscle, and they'll earn their way back to the SEC one day.

Yo ho, yo ho, to the league championship game they go.

---

Week 12 vibe shifts

Each week, the Top 25 endures major shake-ups that transform the college football landscape. But there are more subtle changes every Saturday, too, and we capture those here.

Trending down: Noon kickoffs

Ohio State fans are frustrated with so many noon kickoffs this year, noting that only farmers and nerds wake up before 11 a.m. As it turned out Saturday, it was Northwestern who was still asleep at kickoff.

some tough moments for Northwestern 😬 pic.twitter.com/zARRjzD3B7

— FOX College Football (@CFBONFOX) November 16, 2024

Northwestern somehow held the ball for 32 minutes but managed just 251 yards, spending most of its time on offense working out the details of this year's team Secret Santa program. Thankfully, the game was played at Wrigley Field, and the Cubs' bullpen coughed up 31 points in the middle quarters, with Carnell Tate starring. He hauled in four catches for 52 yards and two touchdowns.

Northwestern is the sixth opponent this season Ohio State has held to single digits. Only Oregon has topped 20 against the Buckeyes.

Trending up: Narrow Texas wins

Quinn Ewers tossed two touchdown passes -- including a 1-yarder with 9:05 to play that effectively sealed a 20-10 win over Arkansas -- but he averaged just 5.5 yards per pass, and the Horns had just 315 yards of total offense, their second-lowest production in a game, trailing only the loss to Georgia.

Texas has now played three bowl-eligible teams this season, and the results have been pretty meh. The Horns were stampeded by Georgia, escaped Vanderbilt by 3 and now struggled offensively against Arkansas in a 10-point win.

The answer here is clear: more Arch Manning. Play him at receiver. Have him provide pre-drive inspiration by reenacting famous motivational scenes from movies such as "Braveheart" or "Weekend at Bernie's," have him challenge Bevo to a foot race at halftime. Whatever it takes to get more Arch on the field, Texas needs to make it happen.

Trending up: ACC irony

SMU held off Boston College 38-28 to move to 6-0 in ACC play, all but assuring the Mustangs of a trip to the ACC championship game in their first season in the league. Kevin Jennings threw for 298 yards and three touchdowns, and Brashard Smith ran for 120 yards and a score.

It's worth noting as SMU moves toward a conference title game appearance, that the only reason it's in the ACC is because NC State changed its vote to approve expansion last year. NC State, in its 72nd season in the ACC, has never played in the ACC championship game, though it has heard it's not that great anyway. Plus, it had plans, like catching up on the new season of "Only Murders in the Building." And maybe a Home Depot trip. And it's just nice to have a staycation after a busy football season. Really, don't worry about NC State. It's doing just fine, and it definitely didn't just DoorDash six pints of Jeni's ice cream.

Trending up: The smell at the Brown residence

— Ashley Wenskoski (@AshleyWenskTV) November 11, 2024

LeQuint Allen ran for 109 yards and two touchdowns, Kyle McCord threw for 323 yards and a score, and both will be getting a nice gift basket from Fran Brown's wife this week after they lifted Syracuse to a 33-25 win over Cal.

— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) November 16, 2024

Brown will presumably wait to shower until the team returns to Syracuse, so everyone on the plane can still enjoy the smell of victory.

On the flip side, Cal lost its fifth one-possession game of the season -- one that would've had the Bears bowl eligible -- and Cal coach Justin Wilcox decided he's boycotting cutting his toe nails, he'll be blasting Smash Mouth's "I'm a Believer" cover on repeat at practice and he won't be throwing away that old tuna sandwich that has been in the office refrigerator until the Bears get win No. 6. Honestly, he had forgotten about the sandwich weeks ago, so this was really just a convenient excuse.

Trending down: Hot seats

Florida already announced Billy Napier would be back next year, and after Saturday's 49-35 win over West Virginia, Baylor decided Dave Aranda will also be back for 2024.

If Sam Pittman survives at Arkansas, too, it'll be a remarkable turn for coaches who entered the season on the hottest of seats, and allow boosters to use all that money typically reserved for buyouts on something more useful, like building a water slide on the moon.

Aranda now has Baylor set for a bowl game, too, after winning four straight. Baylor's offense, in particular, has been a revelation, topping 38 in each of the last four.

Meanwhile at Auburn, boosters have scheduled a meeting at their secret hideout behind the Jimmy Johns, and are just going type in Bobby Petrino's cell number but won't press send until at least halftime of the Iron Bowl.

Trending up: Big man TDs

Southern demolished Arkansas-Pine Bluff 31-9 on Saturday, and senior defensive tackle Willie Miles delivered a play for the ages in the process.

Miles, who according to Southern's media guide checks in at 5-foot-9 and a gentlemanly 350 pounds, picked up a loose ball after a DJ Stevenson fumble, and set his sights on the end zone. A Golden Lions lineman appeared to have him corralled at the 5, but Miles had ice water in his veins -- and also possibly some gravy. He pulled loose from the tackle attempt, spun, gathered his balance, and sprinted for the end zone -- running through the back and around to the sideline where his teammate wisely opted against lifting him into the air "Dirty Dancing" style.

— Kevin Batiste (@KBatisteJr) November 17, 2024

This was a fitting highlight in what was Miles' final home game at Southern, but his rumble will serve as an inspiration to all of us who've broken a sweat while eating pie that, with a little effort, we could be athletes, too.

Trending up: Air mail

At the Utah High School state championships Saturday, a fight for the football happened after a football was dropped from a helicopter hovering over the field.

This is for real, guys. The Utah High School Football State Championship games for lower classifications today had a chopper fly in and drop the game ball instead of a coin toss. One player from each team fighting for possession.#UTPreps @KSLSports @UHSAAinfo pic.twitter.com/tobccmy5kR

— Sam Farnsworth (@Samsworth_TV) November 17, 2024

Though in the long run it did not actually replace the coin toss, it should be implemented as such immediately at all levels of football. However, some schools may not have easy access to a helicopter, so we would also accept wrestling a bear for possession of the football, a wing-eating contest, a break-dancing competition, a series of "Yo Mama" jokes or, if absolutely necessary and only for Ivy League games, a race to see which team can solve the equation from "Good Will Hunting" first.

Trending up: Classy coaches

A week ago, Kennesaw State fired its only coach in program history, Brian Bohannon. First, the school said he resigned. He denied it, and the school relented.

If he's angry at his former employer though, he's sure not taking it out on his players.

— HALL of GOATS (@GOATS_hall) November 17, 2024

Kennesaw State played one of its better games in Bohannon's absence on the sideline, falling to Sam Houston, 23-17, in overtime. But what'll be remembered by most Owls fans is their former coach making a classy gesture in the aftermath of a brutal week. Either that or his moving van has been stuck in traffic on I-75 since Monday.

---

Heisman five

It's really a three-man race for the Heisman now, unless you want to count offensive Travis Hunter and defensive Travis Hunter as separate players, in which case he's going to need to buy another suit for the ceremony.

1. Colorado WR/CB Travis Hunter

Hunter Week 12 touchdown count: 1 scored, 1 allowed.

He should be ashamed of himself, giving up a touchdown like that. It's the type of performance that would get one of Deion Sanders' kids docked three spots on his child ranking list.

2. Boise State RB Ashton Jeanty

Boise State fell behind San José State 14-0 before somebody remembered to wake Jeanty up and tell him to go smash things. He finished the Broncos' 42-21 with 32 carries for 159 yards and three touchdowns, putting Jeanty now just 107 rushing yards shy of 2,000 on the season. Jeanty has also eclipsed 30 carries in five straight games, just the third player of the playoff era to do so.

3. Miami QB Cam Ward

The Hurricanes were off Saturday, giving Ward more time to stew over the loss to Georgia Tech. He has called Brent Key's house 23 times already this week to ask if his refrigerator is running.

4. Oregon QB Dillon Gabriel

Any chance of Gabriel making a real run at the Heisman probably evaporated Saturday in Madison, as he failed to throw a touchdown pass and the Ducks' offense struggled. Only a home game against Washington and the Big Ten title game remain before voting commences. The good news is, after 23 seasons of college football, Gabriel will still be a favorite to take home a lifetime achievement award.

5. Penn State TE Tyler Warren

In Saturday's 49-10 win over Purdue, Warren had eight catches for 127 yards and a touchdown and three carries for 63 yards and a score. All season, he has been Penn State's do-it-all guy, so long as "all" doesn't also include beating Ohio State. He's the first Big Ten non-QB to account for at least 10 touchdowns in a season -- at least one each passing, rushing and receiving -- since 2017, when another Nittany Lion, Saquon Barkley, did it

---

Under-the-radar play of the week

Liberty's kicker was pretty, pretty ... pretty good in overtime of Saturday's 35-34 win over UMass.

Normally, UMass is an easy win, but this one seemed destined to go down like a dry scone. UMass jumped out to a 20-7 halftime lead, with the majority of Liberty's offense coming from pity points. Losing to UMass, of course, is one of the most humiliating things a man can experience along with trying on pants.

But the Flames pulled the old chat-and-cut in the second half, tying the game at 28 with 3:49 to play and forcing overtime. UMass scored first in OT, but kicker Jacob Lurie, who we assume doesn't respect wood, missed his PAT try. Liberty then matched the touchdown and sent Colin Karhu in to win the game with the extra point -- and to stare down the legend, Larry David.

From there, the scoreboard flickered to the actual final score -- 35-34 Liberty -- which feels offensive. They could've at least lied to UMass. A lie is a gesture, it's a courtesy, it's a little respect. This was very disrespectful.

---

Under-the-radar game of the week

Louisville technically joined the ACC in 2014, but it wasn't until Saturday that the Cardinals truly hit the type of rock bottom misery the ACC foists upon all who approach it.

Louisville, which figured to win easily since it has many Cardinals, whereas Stanford is just one Cardinal, cruised early and led by two touchdowns in the fourth quarter. But Stanford scored on a 25-yard touchdown pass with 45 seconds left to tie the game at 35, forced a Louisville turnover on downs after the Cards ran seven plays in just 35 seconds and Stanford got the ball back with 10 seconds to play at its own 45. That should've meant overtime, but Louisville committed an unsportsmanlike penalty, setting up Stanford for a 57-yard field goal try. Quincy Riley then was flagged for being offsides, shaving another 5 yards off the kick, and Emmet Kenney delivered from 52 yards out for the win.

With one minute to play in the game, ESPN gave Louisville a 90% win probability. With 15 seconds left it was still a coin flip. And with no time left on the clock, it was a full-on #goacc for the ages.